Oh, I'll take your word for it - I forgot the smiley when I pointed out the variation in methodology.
My 1911s don't rattle - but then they're custom match guns, and properly (and tightly) fitting the slide to the rails was probably a large part of the cost of building them. As a consequence none of them like to run dirty either.
Whoever rebuilt it last either got lucky and put a slide and frame together that fit well or they intentionally picked them, and/or they tweaked them to make them fit better.
The Ballester Molina I rebuilt a few years ago, while not strictly speaking a 1911, does not rattle any more. I did some work to tighten the slide to frame fitment as well as fitting a match grade barrel to it. It shoots surprisingly well now considering it looks terrible. It was the cheapest grade SARCO had at the time.
SARCO had installed a decent set of springs in it, which was good. The original barrel looked like a sewer pipe. The grips SARCO installed look like hell, but feel better than they look. I've been too lazy to change them considering they aren't the worst part of the cosmetics of the piece and I'm a function over form sort of guy anyway.
You are a guest here when you comment. This is my soapbox, not yours. Be polite. Inappropriate comments will be deleted without mention. Amnesty period is expired.
Do not go off on a tangent, stay with the topic of the post. If I can't tell what your point is in the first couple of sentences I'm flushing it.
If you're trying to comment anonymously: You can't. Log into your Google account.
If you can't comprehend this, don't comment; because I'm going to moderate and mock you for wasting your time.
Now do the first two again with the trigger pinned back - just like you did with the third.
ReplyDeleteWill you take my word that it doesn't make a difference in the Colt and Springfield?
DeleteThe slides are rattling on them, not the trigger.
The Ithaca/Rem-Rand's trigger rattles like a mofo, but not the slide; which is what I wanted to pithily show.
I should add the "mindless amusement" tag to show I'm not too serious here.
Oh, I'll take your word for it - I forgot the smiley when I pointed out the variation in methodology.
ReplyDeleteMy 1911s don't rattle - but then they're custom match guns, and properly (and tightly) fitting the slide to the rails was probably a large part of the cost of building them. As a consequence none of them like to run dirty either.
I'm finding it odd that the ancient and abused mil gun is tighter than the brand new commercial offerings.
DeleteEspecially since the pistol I was issued would rattle when held perfectly still.
Whoever rebuilt it last either got lucky and put a slide and frame together that fit well or they intentionally picked them, and/or they tweaked them to make them fit better.
DeleteThey intentionally picked them. They had bins and bins of parts to go through.
DeleteRefurbishment wasn't done on a one by one basis, but in case lots.
The Ballester Molina I rebuilt a few years ago, while not strictly speaking a 1911, does not rattle any more. I did some work to tighten the slide to frame fitment as well as fitting a match grade barrel to it. It shoots surprisingly well now considering it looks terrible. It was the cheapest grade SARCO had at the time.
ReplyDeleteSARCO had installed a decent set of springs in it, which was good. The original barrel looked like a sewer pipe. The grips SARCO installed look like hell, but feel better than they look. I've been too lazy to change them considering they aren't the worst part of the cosmetics of the piece and I'm a function over form sort of guy anyway.
Delete