The descent into woke at Steve Jackson Games continues apace.
"Sensitivity reading" is the process of editing a manuscript to replace privileged wording – phrasing favored by majorities, the powerful, or the elite, whether in the region of publication or globally – that is offensive to, reinforces negative stereotypes of, or erases the less privileged. Examples include calling a physically disabled person a "cripple," calling a mentally ill individual "nuts," referring to a minority group using a disrespectful exonym, dismissing the contributions of a group, or implying or outright stating that everyone in a certain group is a criminal or less intelligent. The goal of the procedure is to remove negative overtones that target ability, ethnicity, gender, geographical origin, religion, sexual orientation, wealth, etc., rendering the writing more inclusive and equitable without loss of meaning or clarity.
Kromm, GURPS Line Editor
Considering that the people making those sensitivity changes are the epitome of powerful and elite...
But it's an effort doomed to fail.
You cannot make something completely non-offensive to everyone. The fact that the attempt is offending so many people in the hobby is a sure clue to that truth.
A lot of noise is being made about "exonyms" and how they offend the people so labeled.
Gypsy and Eskimo come up most often.
Sioux and Commanche... Those are not the words those tribes called themselves. Those are the, deliberately, offensive labels their neighbors applied to them.
But if I say Oceti Sakowin, or Numunuu, will you know whom I speak of?
The Blackfoot don't call themselves that. They call themselves Siksikáí'tsitapi. You will not find my wife being offended by the name of Blackfoot. Me? I'm saying Blackfoot because I will BUTCHER their name in their language.
I know where Gypsy comes from. The Roma people, living according to their own rules, are not good neighbors. Having earned that reputation, they really haven't earned a lot of right to complain when the stories grew a bit past the truth. And by the way, the only Roma I've met who are offended by the term Gypsy are exactly the same kind of race-grifter you'd expect them to be.
Eskimo vs Inuit is the same thing as Sioux vs Oceti Sakowin. Someone else's name for them. The Inuit are insulted by how Eskimo was used. Fine.
Give English some time, though, and your preferred name will be used in exactly the same way.
Remember, English, despite not being a tonal language, can magically change the word "Sir" to mean CENSORED. I seen't it!
No comments:
Post a Comment
You are a guest here when you comment. This is my soapbox, not yours. Be polite. Inappropriate comments will be deleted without mention. Amnesty period is expired.
Do not go off on a tangent, stay with the topic of the post. If I can't tell what your point is in the first couple of sentences I'm flushing it.
If you're trying to comment anonymously: You can't. Log into your Google account.
If you can't comprehend this, don't comment; because I'm going to moderate and mock you for wasting your time.